A Comparison of Filtering Evaluation Metrics based on Formal Constraints

  • Enrique Amigó
  • Julio Gonzalo
  • Felisa Verdejo
  • Damiano Spina
Information Retrieval Journal, 2019

Although document filtering is simple to define, there is a wide range of different evaluation measures that have been proposed in the literature, all of which have been subject to criticism. Our goal is to compare metrics from a formal point of view, in order to understand whether each metric is appropriate, why and when, and in order to achieve a better understanding of the similarities and differences between metrics. Our formal study leads to a typology of measures for document filtering which is based on (i) a formal constraint that must be satisfied by any suitable evaluation measure, and (ii) a set of three (mutually exclusive) formal properties which help to understand the fundamental differences between measures and determining which ones are more appropriate depending on the application scenario. As far as we know, this is the first in-depth study on how filtering metrics can be categorized according to their appropriateness for different scenarios. Two main findings derive from our study. First, not every measure satisfies the basic constraint; but problematic measures can be adapted using smoothing techniques that and makes them compliant with the basic constraint while preserving their original properties. Our second finding is that all metrics (except one) can be grouped in three families, each satisfying one out of three formal properties which are mutually exclusive. In cases where the application scenario is clearly defined, this classification of metrics should help choosing an adequate evaluation measure. The exception is the Reliability/Sensitivity metric pair, which does not fit into any of the three families, but has two valuable empirical properties: it is strict (i.e. a good result according to reliability/sensitivity ensures a good result according to all other metrics) and has more robustness that all other measures considered in our study.

@article{migo2019filtering,
author="Amig{\'o}, Enrique and Gonzalo, Julio and Verdejo, Felisa and Spina, Damiano",
title={{A Comparison of Filtering Evaluation Metrics Based on Formal Constraints}},
journal="Information Retrieval Journal",
year="2019",
issn="1573-7659",
doi="10.1007/s10791-019-09355-y",
url="https://doi.org/10.1007/s10791-019-09355-y"
}
Damiano Spina